Aza Holmes and her father’s relationship
Turtles All the Way DownAza Holmes and her father’s relationship endures through memory and the objects he left behind, especially a phone that lets her return to his way of seeing and speak to him as if the connection were still immediate. His death does not end her bond with him: it changes its form, from a childhood presence she could summon in imagination to a continuing, sometimes painful attachment carried by photographs, private rituals, and the knowledge that she still misses him.
Identity and Background
Aza Holmes’s father died suddenly, but the relationship remains active in the novel’s present. His old phone is kept with its charging cord hidden in the trunk of Harold, beside the spare tire. That concealment makes the device a private possession rather than simply another family archive. Although Aza’s mother had backed up his pictures and emails to a computer and several hard drives, Aza prefers looking through them on the phone itself. It is the device her father held and spoke into, and it still works eight years after his body stopped working.
The distinction between digital contents and physical object is central to their continuing bond. Aza knows that the pictures exist elsewhere, yet the phone’s connection to her father cannot be reproduced by a backup. Its familiar screen and stored images offer a material route to him: she can handle what he handled and encounter the world as it appeared to him. The phone does not restore his presence, but it gives absence a shape she can return to.
His Photographs and Aza’s Way of Seeing
Her father’s photographs reveal his attention through what he chose to frame. He rarely appears in the pictures himself; instead, the images show Aza, Aza’s mother, and the sky divided by tree branches. Aza is particularly drawn to the branch patterns. While floating beneath a leafless sycamore, she looks up at its crossing limbs and the irregular shapes they make against the blue sky, and recognizes a view that fills many of her father’s photographs. She has wondered what he saw in those split branches. The resemblance joins her present observation to his past attention without requiring her to know exactly what the images meant to him.
A photograph of Aza at seven, leaning far back on a playground swing, carries a different kind of memory. The picture shows her and Aza’s mother at Juan Solomon Park, but Aza’s mother has told her that she remembers the photographs rather than the events they recorded. Aza nevertheless feels she can remember her father pushing her: the swing’s movement away from him also meant swinging back toward him. The image thus holds both the uncertainty of reconstructed childhood memory and the felt assurance of a relationship in which his hands once steadied her.
Among the pictures she revisits is one of her father with a friend at a Pacers game. She chooses it because he is out of focus, an image that suits her sense that people themselves are not always sharply defined. Looking at it, she tells him that she came into some money, intends to try to do right by it, and misses him. The phone becomes not only a store of images but a recipient for news and feeling that she cannot deliver to him in life.
Rituals of Return and Shared Grief
Aza’s returns to the phone recur at moments when she wants privacy or comfort. Before meeting Daisy at Applebee’s, she arrives early, stays in Harold, and reaches into the trunk through the fold-down center of the back seat. She retrieves a tote containing money, her father’s phone, and its charger, then plugs the phone in and waits for it to power up. The deliberate sequence—finding the hidden bag, charging the device, and opening the photographs—turns remembrance into an enacted ritual rather than a passing thought.
After a movie, Aza tells Davis that she is tired because she wants to be alone. Once home, she goes to Harold’s trunk for the phone, sneaks past Aza’s mother, who is asleep on the couch, and sits for a long time swiping through the photographs of the sky broken by branches. When Aza’s mother gently points out that the same photographs are on the computer, Aza unplugs the phone and switches it off. The exchange makes the difference plain: access to the images is not the same as contact with the object her father used. Later, when asked what she had been telling him, Aza calls the conversation private secrets. Aza’s mother says she also tells him secrets and trusts him to keep them, acknowledging the practice instead of treating it as something Aza must abandon.
Memory, Imagination, and Loss
Aza remembers that after her father died, his presence seemed both true and untrue to her. For weeks, she could imagine him returning from mowing the lawn, sweaty and reaching to hug her; even as a child, she would wriggle away because sweat frightened her. In another imagined scene, she lies reading in her room, sees the closed door, and pictures him opening it, kneeling beside her, and kissing the top of her head. These memories preserve the ordinary textures of their relationship as well as its tenderness: his attempts to embrace her, her recoil, and his familiar affection.
Over time, summoning him becomes harder. Aza finds it more difficult to recall his smell or the feeling of being lifted by him, and describes his death as happening both suddenly and across the years. In that account, he is still dying in the gradual loss of accessible details and, in that sense, still living in the continuing work of remembering. For Aza, imagination and memory do not fall into separate compartments: she remembers what she has imagined and imagines what she remembers. The relationship therefore persists without a clean boundary between an actual childhood event and a scene reconstructed after his death.
The Phone’s Destruction and the Bond’s Continuation
The phone’s vulnerability becomes explicit after Aza and Daisy’s car accident. In pain from her ribs, Aza struggles to open Harold’s trunk and reaches inside until she finds her father’s phone. Its screen is shattered; when she tries to turn it on, only a cloudy gray light appears beneath the broken glass. She knows that the photographs are backed up and that their contents have not been lost, but that assurance does not resolve her grief. It was his phone: he held it, spoke into it, and used it to take her picture. Aza runs her thumb across the broken screen and cries, mourning the damage to the physical link even though the images remain elsewhere.
The episode clarifies what the phone has meant throughout the relationship. Its value never rested only on the information it contained. It was a thing that had belonged to her father and passed through his hands, so its breakage feels like a fresh loss that a duplicate file cannot cancel. Yet the connection is not confined to the device: Aza’s memories, imagined encounters, conversations with him, and photographs continue after the screen goes dark. In the months that follow, she keeps going while acknowledging that she misses her father. The bond remains part of her life, not a problem solved by either preserving every object or forgetting him.

